Skip to main content

Daniel K. Inouye Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies Home

Daniel K. Inouye Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies

  • Request new password
  • Login with PKI
Log in with CAC
Forgot Password?
  • Home
  • News
    • Topics
  • Events
  • Workshops
    • Enhancing Maritime Safety in the Asia-Pacific
    • Maritime Shared Awareness in SE Asia III
    • Disaster Response Regional Architecture
    • National Security Coordination in Southeast Asia
    • Building Maritime Capacity: A Quadrilateral Approach
    • Countering Violent Extremism in Southeast Asia 2
    • Integrating Private, Civil & Public Sector DR
    • COVID-19 and Beyond
    • Gray Zone Activities in Great Power Competition
    • Norms in Space: Exploring Asia-Pacific Perspectives
  • Daniel K. Inouye Asia-Pacific Center for Securi...
  • U.S. Command and Control across the Spectrum of...

U.S. Command and Control across the Spectrum of Gray-Zone Operations in the East China Sea

Print Share Download PDF
2 comments

murky.jpg

murky
From APCSS | by Daniel Lambert | 26 May 2021

“U.S. Command and Control across the Spectrum of Gray-Zone Operations in the East China Sea” is a new essay by DKI APCSS professors Dr. John Hemmings and Prof. Wade Turvold published by the National Bureau of Asian Research (NBR) in its special report, “Murky Waters in the East China Sea Chinese Gray-Zone Operations and U.S.-Japan Alliance Coordination.” The essay examines the role of the U.S. in gray-zone contingencies in the East China Sea in the context of alliance coordination with Japan.

Executive Summary:
The U.S. and Japan produced the New Defense Guidelines in 2015 that created the alliance coordination mechanism (ACM) to enable the allies to better manage crises. The ACM has proved useful but is showing some limitations in handling the challenges of complex gray-zone activity posed by China. This is in part due to the differing definitions of “gray zone” in Japan and the U.S., which could lead to confusion over appropriate response mechanisms. This uncertainty may have the unintended effect of giving China the power to set the tempo of activities in and around the Senkaku Islands to incrementally wrest control from the Japan Coast Guard. There are also growing concerns that the ACM is insufficient for dealing with kinetic operations above the threshold of gray-zone operations. Therefore, the U.S. and Japan should consider reforming the ACM, reorganizing U.S. Forces Japan, and developing a command and control (C2) structure for crises just below and above the gray-zone threshold.

POLICY IMPLICATIONS

  • Japan and the U.S. must find a common definition of gray zone that will enable them to agree on the threshold where gray-zone activity ends and conflict begins.
  • Japan and the U.S. must strengthen the ACM by constant usage and rehearsal in order to allow it to function properly during a fait accompli gray-zone operation by China.
  • The disjointedness of U.S. C2 in the vicinity of Japan could be a significant challenge in a fast-paced crisis above the gray-zone threshold. The allies should consider creating a unified command structure for the alliance, given that the current “coalition-style” approach to C2 could prove insufficient for dealing with a peer competitor with a unified command in a crisis scenario.

READ ARTICLE

Dr. John Hemmings and Prof. Wade Turvold are professors at the Daniel K. Inouye Asia-Pacific Center for Security Studies (DKI APCSS) in Honolulu, USA. The views expressed in this essay are the author’s alone, and do not necessarily reflect the official position of the DKI APCSS or the United States Government.

Building Partnership Capacity, Cooperative Security, Policy and Planning Development, Security Studies , Japan
See all tags »

Associated Files

Related Stories

Russian global reach
Information Literacy
DKI APCSS professor contribute to book on Russia’s Global Reach
China Gray Zone Operations
International Organizations
China's Gray Zone Operations in the Yellow Sea
See all related stories »
 

About APCSS

APCSSLink is a portal within the Department of Defense GlobalNet portal for regional security studies centers. It is made available to Alumni and workshop participants. There is an online help guide and additional help can be obtained by contacting us at: apcsslinkadmin@dkiapcss.net


About APCSSLink
Contact Us

Find us on Social Media

Footer: About GlobalNET

GlobalNET represents a network of organizations and their representative members who are working to foster national and international collaboration as well as to maintain relationships, and strengthen partner capacity.

Footer: GlobalNET Main Links

  • About GlobalNET
  • Contact GlobalNET
  • GlobalNET Partners

Footer: GlobalNET Partner

These are the GlobalNET partners

GlobalNET Support

  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Help Desk
  • How to use GlobalNET
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use